Imagine you’re throwing a party, but instead of inviting a group of friends with similar interests, you send out a blanket invitation to everyone you know — from your gym buddy to your grandmother’s book club. Chances are, not everyone will be excited about the same activities or vibe. Email marketing works in much the same way. Without proper segmentation, you’re essentially inviting people to a party they might not be interested in, and your message can get lost in the crowd.

So, What Exactly is Segmentation?

Segmentation is the practice of dividing your email list into smaller, more targeted groups based on specific criteria like behaviour, demographics, or past interactions. Whether you’re dealing with 100 or 100,000 subscribers, segmentation allows you to speak directly to your audience’s individual needs, making your email campaigns more relevant and personal.

Think about it — people engage differently based on various factors. Some might have just discovered your brand, others may be regular buyers, while some could be window shoppers who haven’t hit that ‘buy’ button yet. Segmentation helps you categorise these different groups, tailoring your message to each. For example, you could send one email to new subscribers welcoming them to your community and another to long-time customers offering them exclusive discounts.

Why Segmentation Works

The reason segmentation drives higher ROI is simple: relevance. People are more likely to engage with content that speaks directly to their needs, interests, or behaviour. Imagine receiving an email that addresses a problem you’re currently facing or offers a product you’ve been eyeing — you’re far more likely to take action, right?

Let’s break it down further. When you segment your audience, you can target:

  • Where they came from: Did they sign up through social media, your website, or perhaps at an in-person event? This insight can guide how you speak to them and what offers you might present.
  • Their purchase history: Have they bought from you before? If yes, what have they purchased? Someone who has already shown interest in your products will be more inclined to hear about upgrades, accessories, or complementary services.
  • Their level of engagement: Are they opening your emails, clicking on links, or have they gone cold? You can re-engage dormant subscribers with special offers or share relevant content with your active audience to keep them interested.

Personalisation: The Cherry on Top

Segmentation is the gateway to personalisation — which, let’s be honest, we all love. Who doesn’t like to feel special? By breaking your audience down into more specific groups, you can create highly personalised emails that deliver real value. Instead of receiving a generic ‘hello’, they get a message tailored to their actions, preferences, and interests. This can make your brand stand out in a crowded inbox, and that’s half the battle in email marketing.

Real-Life Example of Segmentation Success

Let’s say you’re an online retailer selling sports gear. You have a massive list of subscribers, but you notice your engagement rates are low, and your sales aren’t reflecting your efforts. Instead of sending out generic promotions, you decide to segment your audience. You break your list down into groups based on past purchases — one for those who’ve bought running shoes, another for those who’ve purchased hiking gear, and a third for those who’ve shown interest in yoga equipment.

For the running shoe buyers, you send a targeted email showcasing the latest running gear, while the hiking group gets an offer on backpacks and outdoor essentials. Yoga enthusiasts receive an email featuring eco-friendly mats and accessories. By speaking directly to their interests, you’re providing value and increasing the likelihood of conversion.

And guess what? When you measure the results, you’ll likely see a significant uptick in engagement and sales, all thanks to segmentation.

But Doesn’t This Take More Time?

Yes, segmenting your list and crafting targeted content does require extra effort. But think of it as an investment that pays dividends in the long run. The more relevant your emails, the better your open rates, click-through rates, and conversions will be. Plus, most email marketing platforms offer tools that make it easy to automate the segmentation process, so you’re not manually sorting through your entire subscriber list every time you hit ‘send’.

Ready to Segment Your Way to Success?

If you’re currently sending the same email to your entire list and hoping for the best, now is the time to rethink your strategy. Start by looking at the data you already have on your subscribers — where they signed up, what they’ve purchased, and how they engage with your emails. Then, create segments based on that information and craft messages that resonate with each group.

Once you’ve experienced the power of segmentation, you’ll never go back to blanket emailing again.

So, which segment of your audience are you most excited to reach out to first?

FeedbackFans.com Managing Director - Chris Barnard

Chris Barnard has spent over 15 years delivering exceptional digital marketing performance for ambitious businesses in the UK, Europe and North America through his marketing technology business, FeedbackFans.com and as an independent business consultant.

FeedbackFans provides a unique next-generation managed technology and marketing platform that delivers outstanding and outsized results for businesses in sectors such as finance, retail, leisure, and professional services.

With our unparalleled expertise in creating cutting-edge solutions and environments, we empower our clients and users to thrive and outperform in the digital age.

Chris Barnard is Managing Director of FeedbackFans.com and producer of the Bear Business Vodcast